
Collage of forgeries from the Eric Spoutz case. FBI. Image source ↗
Michigan and New York, United States
Federal prosecutors announced Eric Spoutz’s arrest on a fraud charge over dozens of works allegedly misattributed to American artists. This report records the February 2016 charge, not a conviction. His later sentence is covered separately on the site.

Hieronymus Bosch / Faithful reproduction of a public-domain two-dimensional artwork; image supplied in the source notice. · Resized for display Image source ↗
Kansas City, Missouri, United States
The Bosch Research and Conservation Project attributed the Nelson-Atkins Temptation of Saint Anthony to Bosch himself. Infrared investigation and comparison of surviving original brushwork supported the conclusion despite heavy later retouching. Long catalogued as a follower’s work, the panel was selected for the 2016 Bosch exhibition in ’s-Hertogenbosch.

Jan van Eyck / Faithful reproduction of a public-domain two-dimensional artwork; image supplied in the source notice. · Resized for display Image source ↗
New York, United States
X-radiography at the Metropolitan Museum exposed fragmentary Flemish lettering under gold overpaint on the frames of the Crucifixion and Last Judgment. The discovery supplied evidence for investigation of the panels’ original arrangement and purpose; it did not by itself settle whether they began as a diptych or triptych.

Kiwiodysee Image source ↗
Los Angeles, United States
Jonathan Markell received eighteen months in federal prison after guilty pleas concerning antiquity smuggling and a charitable-deduction scheme. The judgment also required repatriation of seized objects. Prosecutors linked the trade to looting at Ban Chiang and other Asian sites.

New York, United States
Christie’s withdrew an eighth-century BCE Celtic bronze dagger and scabbard from its New York antiquities auction after an antiquities researcher linked the objects to records in the Becchina archive and raised concerns about possible looting. Photo: the dagger and scabbard in the Becchina archive, via ARCA and Artnet.

Kenneth C. Zirkel Image source ↗
Princeton, United States and Rome, Italy
Princeton University Art Museum transferred ancient works to Italy amid concerns about illicit excavation. Princeton Alumni Weekly reported that the returned objects were displayed in Rome in December 2015. It was a later transfer after the museum’s separate 2007 agreement.

N.C. Wyeth, The Encounter on Freshwater Cliff. FBI recovery photograph. Image source ↗
Maine and Boston, United States
The FBI announced that the last two paintings from a 2013 Maine theft were surrendered on 9 October 2015. Four others had been recovered in December 2014. The investigation remained open at publication.

Photo: ajay_suresh. Image source ↗
New York, United States
Further provenance work identified the landscape in the museum as a picture from Max Fischer’s collection. MoMA returned the painting to his heirs.

United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri Image source ↗
St. Louis, Missouri, United States
Photographer Kennedy challenged an agency’s use of low-resolution images in advertising samples. The district court found fair use for internal evaluation materials, while leaving factual issues about distribution to the client for further proceedings.

FBI New York Image source ↗
Orient, New York, United States
The FBI returned a maritime painting reported stolen in March 2001. A buyer researched it in the FBI’s stolen-art database and contacted investigators. The agency said in 2015 that three other items reported stolen in that case were still sought.

Blackhorsemedia / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Resized for display Image source ↗
San Francisco, California, United States
The Ninth Circuit affirmed judgment against Mark Towle over unauthorised replicas of the Batmobile from the 1966 television series and 1989 film. It treated the Batmobile as a sufficiently distinctive copyrightable character whose recognisable traits persisted across depictions. The ruling concerned this particular character and replicas, not every vehicle design.

Canon table by T’oros Roslin. Getty Museum via Google Arts & Culture. Public domain. Image source ↗
Los Angeles, United States
The Getty acknowledged the Armenian Apostolic Church’s ownership of eight leaves from the Zeyt’un Gospels. Under the agreement, the Church agreed to donate the leaves to the museum.

Ken Lund from Reno, Nevada, USA Image source ↗
Chicago, Illinois, United States
A photographer challenged an altered version of his image used by the Illinois Republican Party. The district court found fair use after weighing the photograph’s factual character and the potential market effect, while recognizing similarities to the original.

Rembrandt van Rijn / Faithful reproduction of a public-domain two-dimensional artwork; image supplied in the source notice. · Resized for display Image source ↗
Maastricht, Netherlands; New Jersey, United States
A panel catalogued as nineteenth-century Continental school at a New Jersey auction in September 2015 was recognised as Rembrandt’s Sense of Smell. It was shown at TEFAF in March 2016 after acquisition for the Leiden Collection. The painting restored a missing member of the young artist’s series of senses.

FBI New York Image source ↗
New York, United States
The Ambassadors of Rome Offering the Throne to Numa Pompilio had been stolen from a Santiago residence in 2006. It resurfaced in a New York auction consignment in 2014. The FBI took custody with assistance from INTERPOL and returned it to the owner’s lawyer in September 2015.

Beverly Hills, United States / London, United Kingdom
A posthumous bronze cast stolen in 1991 resurfaced in London and was recovered in 2015. It was offered back to its rightful owner.

New York, United States
Sotheby’s withdrew a late thirteenth-century Madonna and Child from auction after it was identified as stolen from a Geneva vault in 1986. A settlement resolved the ownership dispute in 2015. The possible attribution to Duccio remained open.

Jasper Johns and James Meyer in the studio. Photograph: Hans Namuth, via the cited source. Image source ↗
New York and Connecticut, United States
James Meyer was sentenced to 18 months in prison for selling 37 works stolen from Jasper Johns’s Connecticut studio. Prosecutors described fabricated documentation used to reassure buyers about the works’ provenance.

Americasroof Image source ↗
New York, United States
Collectors challenged actions by the Keith Haring Foundation over works they said were by Haring. A federal district judge granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the claims in March 2015. The ruling dealt with the pleaded legal claims and did not authenticate the artworks.

New York, USA and France
Prosecutors sought civil forfeiture of the painting stolen in France and shipped from Belgium under a false declaration. Proceedings were pending.

Photo: Ajay Suresh from New York, NY, USA. Image source ↗
Manhattan, United States; Italy
An American repatriation ceremony transferred a painting attributed to Giambattista Tiepolo and an Etruscan bronze Herakles figurine to Italy’s cultural heritage police.